Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

That's why the US is developing tracked laser communication systems. They are effectively impossible to jam.


Laser is line of sight, limiting your range. And nature has a great way of jamming lasers, called clouds. If you were able to get a decently powered laser in a satellite, it wouldn't be able to control too many aircraft unless it looked like a porcupine. And then it would have to deal with anti-satellite defenses that both China and Russia have spent significant sums on.


> Laser is line of sight, limiting your range.

Yes, with current equipment it limits your range to somewhere beyond the orbit of the moon. Yes, we can now keep a laser and a receiver tracked on each other from 300000km away.

> And nature has a great way of jamming lasers, called clouds.

There are wavelengths that are not hampered much by clouds.

> If you were able to get a decently powered laser in a satellite

We can.

> it wouldn't be able to control too many aircraft unless it looked like a porcupine.

... but this is a problem, you'd basically be limited in total bandwidth by count of satellites. Meaning you either need to launch a lot of them, or reduce bandwidth per drone.


Being able to ping the moon with a laser doesn't help with terrestrial systems. Just as radar has a horizon limit, so do laser systems. So if you put this on a controller version of an AWACS, you have to deal with attenuation from clouds/weather, and I think keeping a lock on a maneuvering UCAS might be a challenge.


I'm not talking about pinging the moon, I'm talking about maintaining a link with a maneuvering spacecraft in moon orbit.


So this spacecraft you're linking to makes radical 8g maneuvers, changes direction at a 30s/ roll rate, and can change altitude at will?


Unless you happen to have an autonomous reusable spacecraft with significant cross range ability and enough fuel to continuously change orbits.


Not sure why this was downvoted.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: